BBC Tyne Sport
The Alan Shearer interview
All your questions answered!
29th July 2004
"We asked you to pose your
questions to Alan Shearer when he came to our BBC studios for a radio
interview with Newcastle United commentator Mick Lowes. The phonelines
went berserk, as people called and texted their questions to the show.
Here on the web site, we had hundreds of your questions submitted to us.
Some were unprintable, others off the wall, but all entries were greatly
appreciated. Unfortunately, due to time, we could not get Alan to answer
them all, but we would like to thank everyone who took part."
BBC
Radio Newcastle organised a question and answer session with Alan Shearer
in the warmup to the 2004-5 season. Click
HERE for more info and if you want to listen to it click
HERE (if the links don't work ... well it's coz it's broken).
It’s exactly eight years to the day that
Alan Shearer became the world’s most expensive player and he celebrates
the anniversary taking your questions. World’s most expensive once, still
one of the planet’s biggest name in football, but first and foremost a
Geordie and proud skipper of his beloved Newcastle United.
MICK LOWES:
David Maughn from Jarrow has been on the e-mail. He says, to be fair
to David, it was he who alerted us to the fact, as today is the
anniversary of your signing for Newcastle, do you have any regrets?
ALAN SHEARER:
No. It is a very good question to start with. There was three big
reasons why I came here. Obviously one of them was to win silverware, that
has not happened. The second one was because I wanted to work with Kevin
Keegan, he was a hero of mine. And probably more important then anything
is because I wanted to play football for my home town club, Newcastle
United. Anyone that has lived here and was brought up here will surely
understand that reason. To wear the No. 9 shirt at Newcastle, and
obviously captain them for the last few years, it has been everything I
hoped it would be and a hell of a lot more. People have to appreciate the
feeling I get running out at St James' Park, at the front, with the
armband on, with the No. 9 shirt on, it does not get any bigger or better
than that for me.
ML:
In terms of that day back in July 1996, do you still remember it pretty
vividly, the stage behind, the Leazes End. Ian Coulson from Washington:
When you signed from the Toon back in '96, I was in the crowd outside St
James' Park, can you remember what was going through your mind?
AS:
I can. It was great excitement. Probably a few nerves as well because I
remember when I went to the dressing room at Blackburn to say goodbye to
all my team-mates, I remember Tim Sherwood saying to me, "what is the
price?". I turned round and said, "I think it is just over £15 million".
He said, "there is no pressure on you then?!" I thought, "Thanks very much".
It has always been a dream of mine to come up here. I remember that day
fantastically well. It was pouring with rain, there was thousands out
behind in the Leazes End. When I walked out on the platform and gave
everyone a wave, the cheer was fantastic.
ML:
You have dominated Newcastle United since arriving, the manager went on
record, most people went on record last week, as saying that Patrick
Kluivert is probably the biggest signing since Alan Shearer. One on the
text from Alan Richardson in Venezuela. As a Toon Fanatic for 45 years it
thrills me to see lots of people in South America wear black and white
strips with Shearer on the back. When I talk to people here about
Newcastle United, they only know Alan Shearer. Have you ever felt that
sometimes we are a one man team with only one international star and other
clubs have four or five people know?
AS:
I think that is being a tad disrespectful to some of the players. I have
done my job, I think, over the past eight years. My job and my brief is to
score goals and that is what I'm paid to do. Thankfully I have done that
over the years since I've been here. Hopefully there is a few more to come
this season. I think that is a tad disrespectful.
ML:
That is from Venezuela. I don't suppose he can hear unless he is on the
World Wide Web. Let's go to our first call of the evening, you can ring up
and put your point across, Roger from Morpeth is on the line. Roger, what
you want to say?
ROGER:
Hello Alan.
AS:
Hi.
R:
I am a Blackburn fan, I'm not one of them that who boo you.
AS:
It has got less and less as the years have gone by.
R:
No, the crowd has got smaller! When you left did you think you would win
more medals, you must have done?
AS:
Yes. Of course I did. One of the main reasons for me coming here was to
win some silverware. If you cast your mind back then, Newcastle were the
big rivals to Manchester United. I think the season before hand they had
blown that big lead they had over Man Utd. Man Utd clawed their way back.
I was brought here to try close that gap. There is no guarantees in
football. You make the decision, as I did, there is only two or three
teams every year that can win something in our league. There are big teams
in our league and it has been unfortunate, bad luck, it's been we haven't
been good enough, call it what you want. But the fact of the matter is, I
and Newcastle have not won anything for a long time. It has been too long
because of our magnificent fans up here. As I said...
R:
Do you find it easier going back to Blackburn?
AS:
I do to be honest. I was a little hurt
when I first went back there but I think the response I get from the fans
now is very good. I think they appreciate that when I made a decision that
I wanted to make, it was funny because when I was about to leave Blackburn
every phone call or every letter, every time I went out on the street,
what that they said to me was, "please do not go to Man Utd. Go anywhere
but Man Utd". So I come to Newcastle and still get stick when I come back.
But that is part and parcel of football. I have always said it in my mind
that if when go to opposing grounds, fans do not boo bad players so I have
always taken it in the good term.
ML:
Will you stop booing him when he finishes playing, not you particularly,
but the Blackburn fans?
R:
No comment after watching the match with Geordies.
ML:
That was Roger from Morpeth. We have had a text about the Arsenal game,
your debut and a hat-trick against Arsenal for Southampton. Brings us on
to another e-mail question. Paul in Stoke wants to know, what you think
has been the best game in your career? I'm sure you have been asked a
million times, what is your best goal or your best goal in black and white,
your best game - does one game stick out? Holland in Euro 96?
AS:
Probably. It was one of the best atmospheres I played in, in Euro 96, at
Wembley in front of 80, 90,000. The funny thing it is that two, three,
four weeks prior to the tournament we were locked up in our training camp
and did not understand what was going on outside with the public. Of
course it was going crazy and everybody was taken away with Euro 96 and
the atmosphere at Wembley was fantastic. The Dutch shirts, and the England
supporters were mixing very well and we got a great result and I was lucky
enough to get two goals, which was the icing on the cake. Of course in
that tournament as well we beat Scotland which made it even better!
ML:
Club games, does one club game stick out, that debut against Arsenal
must have been very, very special?
AS:
That is one I will always remember obviously because it was my first
start in professional football and to score a hat-trick was beyond my
wildest dreams again such a club as Arsenal. At 17 years of age as well,
which is still a record for top-flight football. Hopefully it will stand
for a long time. To go in there at that age and score three goals,
probably did not appreciate at the time because I was so young. At that
age you take everything in your stride and whatever happens will happen.
Probably not til six or seven years on you think what a decent achievement
it was.
ML:
Mention of England at Wembley brings us on, Charlie Carter from London
has e-mailed in. Alan you are my hero, have you ever regretted your choice
to give up international football?
AS:
No. I have never regretted it at all to be honest because over the past
four years, I think it has been four years since I retired, just after
Euro 2000 I think it was. The reasons I give still stand to this day. I
think my performances over the past four years have justified my decision
to retire from international football. It is nice when you hear people, "come
back and play for England", "come back and play in Euro 2004". But as I
said the reasons that I gave have happened. I have been able to maintain a
very high standard of football over the last four years and I'm not sure I
would have been able to have done that if I had played for Newcastle and
England, particularly with the injuries I had.
ML:
Let's move back to the club side of things, Stephen from Durham is on
the line, Stephen you are through to Alan Shearer.
STEPHEN:
Hello Alan.
AS:
Hi.
S:
I am a Middlesborough fan.
AS:
That is not your fault, everybody has their fault.
S:
No doubt you will be looking forward to running out on the Riverside on
the first game of the season.
AS:
I am.
S:
They fancy their chances of beating you, they have got Viduka now and
Hasselbaink and we won a Cup at last.
AS:
I think the signings that Steve McClaren has made this pre-season have
been very, very good. I think Viduka and Hasselbaink will form a
tremendous partnership and if they can hit it off then it can cause
problems for opposing defences. Hopefully not too much of problem for our
defence on the first day of the season. There is Ray Parlour, Reiziger as
well, he is added experience in there and they are all big-name players he
has signed. I'm sure the expectations for Middlesbrough fans will be very
high, particularly after winning a trophy.
ML:
I know that the Tyne-Tees Derby is a big game in any calendar,
particularly now that Tyne-Wear Derby is missing for the moment, this game
has taken on extra dimensions of late because Middlesbrough, not only a
Derby, they are also vying to be where you are, they are vying to get into
Europe, they have made big money signings, you have local bragging rights
up for grabs. You have a great record there, it promises to be a really
good game the first game?
AS:
Middlesbrough are in Europe the same as we are. I am sure that was a
factor in the big names going to Middlesbrough in the summer. As I said
earlier, I'm sure what has happened at the Riverside is that expectations
will soar, rightly so. They will be wanting to call themselves the top
dogs in the North East and there is a lot for stake this season.
ML:
Someone was telling me, I know you are a betting man, I think Newcastle
are about 10-1 to be top of the Premiership after that first 10 games. Now
the start you have got, irrespective of whether you get anything at the
Riverside, that has got be a good bet hasn't it?
AS:
I am a betting man. I don't mind the odd pound here or there. You are
right in what you say, if we can get off to a good start at the Riverside
the games following that are winnable games without doubt. It is not until
October or November that we meet what the so-called top three. They are
games we will be looking to take maximum points from. But when you look at
the fixtures and you say, "these are games that we should win", how many
times do they turn round and you kick in the teeth and you do not win them?
No. That is why you always get, hear players coming out with that boring
old tag, "we will take one game at a time". If we can get off to a good
start at the Riverside then hopefully the momentum will carry us though
because that was our problem last season.
ML:
You have got to have a better start than last season?
AS:
One of the big factors was confidence because we got knocked out of the
Champions' League qualifier which was a big dent to everyone and a big
blow to everyone, the players, the management, just the whole football
club. I think confidence was dented then and it took as a long time to get
over that. Once you give teams like Arsenal, Man Utd, Chelsea points start
it is very difficult to catch them up because they are high-quality teams
and we cannot afford to do that.
ML:
Stephen in Chester-le-Street mentioned Viduka and Hasselbaink. It is a
fair way from Chester-le-Street to New York City, but Hussain has e-mailed
us, who has been your favourite strike partner during your illustrious
career and why?
AS:
Probably two. One at international level was Teddy Sheringham. We had
such a great relationship, he knew what I was going to do instantly and I
knew what he was going to do. He played in a little hole if you like, it
is very difficult for defenders to go and mark him. If a defender goes
with him then he leaves a gap in behind him which Teddy was fantastic at
turning and playing little balls though. We had a great thing going. He
complimented me, I complimented him. Our relationship at international
level was successful. At club level, I have to say I have been fortunate
enough to play with Chris Sutton. We scored a hell of a lot of goals at
Blackburn. Mike Newall. Matt Le Tissier at Southampton was very, very good.
But I would have to say Les Ferdinand in our one and only a season we
played here together at Newcastle. I think we got 49 or 50 goals when we
played together in that season as a partnership. It was one of those that
we hit it off straight away. We did not really train together, hadn't
played together, just gone in and one of those things that clicked. We
terrorised defences that season and it was a shame that Les had to go in
the way he did because we had a great thing going.
ML:
I know we touched upon it, but we will come back to it because of the
two names you mentioned there. Teddy Sheringham, 38, Sir Les is 37, Paul
Ince is still going in the Premiership and 36. I saw a good interview with
Teddy Sheringham through the summer, he said two things tell you whether
you should carry on. Your body will tell you if you should carry on and
the fact that the phone stops ringing and nobody wants you! That tells you
you should stop playing. You have gone the other way, you have decided
that is that. Clearly some players decide that they want to go on for
another season. Are you surprised that the likes of Teddy Sheringham, Les
Ferdinand, Paul Ince, who are wealthy men, very wealthy men, are still
wanting to play on?
AS:
No. I am not surprised at all. Those
three names you mentioned, they are great professional players and they
have looked after their bodies. The big thing that has not happened to
them, they have not had serious injuries. I have had three serious
injuries. I have been unlucky with injuries but on the other hand I have
been lucky because I've not had the niggling injuries, I'm touching wood
here, that a lot of people get. When I've been injured it has been a
serious injury. I snapped my ankle, tore my cruciate ligament and had a
big problem with my tendon. Those were serious injuries and on another day
could have finished a player. But I think he is right in what he says,
your body will tell you when you know it is time to retire. But as I said,
I will go back to what I said, I plan to retire at the top. Although they
are, apart from Paul Ince and Teddy now, they will be both playing in the
First Division as it was, whatever it is called. And Les will...
ML:
The Coca-Cola Championship!
AS:
Something like that. I lose track of it. Les will be playing at Bolton
and all those three three players will still do very well for those clubs.
Let's go back to the calls, go back to the phones, Gateshead - David
Huddart. You're on the line, you are through to the Newcastle United
skipper. What is your question?
DAVID HUDDART:
Hiya. Hi Alan. I should know your name I have watched you long enough.
Sorry I'm probably nervous talking to you. Alan, I have come from a
massive family of Newcastle supporters. We obviously want to see our team
win a trophy.
AS:
Not as desperate as I am!
DH:
I can imagine. We obviously want to see them win a trophy for ourselves
but not just for that, for you as well with it being your last season. The
question I want to ask you, do you feel honestly in your heart that
looking at the squad that we are going into the new season with this
season, we possibly have a better chance than we did at the beginning of
last season? How do you rate it?
AS:
I said probably three or four days ago that when you enter a competition
you enter it to win it. We go into the Premier League season trying to win
the Premier League. If I'm honest I do not think we will win it. I think
it will be challenging the top three again in Arsenal, Man Utd and Chelsea
this year. I have to say I think we have a very, very realistic chance of
winning the FA Cup or League Cup, whatever that is called now. We
certainly have to try and get to the Uefa Cup and progress again as we did
last year. We got to the semi-final but were not good enough to go that
final yard if you like. With the players we have signed, we have signed
Patrick Kluivert, Nicky Butt, James Milner and who knows, maybe another
before the start the season, I do not know that. In those three players,
particularly in Nicky Butt and Patrick Kluivert's case, they have
experience. Both have experience of winning things. That has to be a big
bonus and a big help us.
ML: I know
you are a fan of Gary Speed, because you were a great friend of Gary
Speed, and I know a lot of people listening to this were disappointed by
the sale of Gary Speed but nothing in football surprises you, how
important was it that they brought Nicky Butt in as a replacement for Gary
Speed?
AS: I think
it was very important because, with Hugo going, we would have went into
the season with Kieron Dyer, Jermaine Jenas, Lee Bowyer, have I missed
another one?
ML:
Laurent Robert.
AS:
Laurent Robert, Darren Ambrose and when you look at that midfield it is
very light weight. What Nicky Butt will do, he will do the same job as
what Speedo did. He will sit in front of the back four, he will control
things, organise things, use his experience well. Where we perhaps might
miss Speedo is from set pieces. Both defending and attacking. He was a
constant threat for us when we had free kicks, and he gave us a big
advantage when we defended them as well because he was so good in the air.
That is where we might miss him.
ML:
Going back to what you said about cup competitions, I have to ask you
this one. I was at a talk in last week with Tony Green and Tommy Cassidy,
two great names of yesteryear. Tommy Cassidy brought the house down at the
Federation Brewery by having a bit of a go at Newcastle's selection policy
last season with regard to the Carling Cup and the fact we had a
Middlesbrough fan on tonight saying, we've got a Cup, we are in Europe,
you have not got a cup so to speak. I know it is not your job, and it is a
bit unfair, do you think the Carling Cup this season should be taken a
little bit more seriously?
AS:
I think it will. It was taken seriously last year. Obviously we created
a hell of a lot of chances in the West Brom game and it was frustrating
for me sat on the bench. But the manager has to try and put players in at
some stage and he has seen that opportunity to try and do that. It did not
work that evening, that was disappointing, not only for myself but all the
players and the manager because it was a chance for us to win some
silverware. I'm sure going into the FA Cup, going into the Carling Cup
this year, we will be going all-out to try and win everything.
ML:
Going back to the e-mails, Philip in Newcastle. Which penalty miss would
you say hurt the most, the one against Sunderland in the Derby or the
Champions' League qualifier? I was in tears for both, PS should I call my
dog Alan?
AS:
If you call it Alan it probably won't listen to you, and won't want to
do what you tell it. Penalties, I will never ever criticise anyone that
misses a penalty. I was sat in the Caribbean in the summer when England
went out to Portugal on penalties. David Beckham got some criticism for
missing his penalty, I think he has missed three on the spin now for
England. But you have to show tremendous courage to get up there in the
first place. You can take as many penalties as you want on the training
ground, practice 9-5, seven days a week, but you will not create that
atmosphere you get when you go out and take them in penalty shoot-outs and
such important penalties, ie. Champions' League qualifiers and in the last
10 minutes against Sunderland to get three points out of the game. But,
which one, it is a tough one. I have to say the Sunderland one because
they are such close rivals of us.
ML:
I'm sure the chairman will say the other one!
AS:
You just took the words out of my mouth. The chairman, if he is
listening, he would say it cost the club a lot more money to go out the
Champions' League than it did to miss that one against Sunderland. But the
stick and the criticism that I got from everyone, and still do, for
missing that one again Sunderland, it took a long time to get over.
ML:
This might be a bit harsh of me, have you missed a greater percentage of
your penalties in recent years, is there a reason for that? You very
rarely used to miss, and you have missed a few of late, is that because
you were young, fancy free, now you think about it a bit more, you are are
a bit older?
AS:
You have obviously looked at the record...
ML:
No I haven't, it is just off the top of my head.
AS:
I might beg to differ. Someone might be out there and able to ring in
and say whether that fact is correct or not. On average, over the years,
and I would say even when I took them at Blackburn, I think I missed about
two a season. That was my last count anyway.
ML:
We will have to get the fellow from Morpeth back on!
AS:
Yes, someone who is out there I'm sure will ring up and tells us that
might be different. If my mind serves me correctly, it is about two a
season, when I've been getting about seven or eight. You are in a no-win
situation. You are expected to score obviously. The keeper, if he saves it,
he is a hero. What you shouldn't do is miss the target which I've done
once or twice obviously. People say from 12 yards, you get paid all this
money, you shouldn't miss the target from 12 yards. They are right, you
shouldn't.
ML:
We will take a break in a second as we are about halfway through, we
will get on to one of the more serious issues. Joey Nichol from Tantobie
has texted in. What are your plans for the future after you do hang up
your boots, now you have 99.9% told us, I'm sure you having yet ...
AS:
Where is Tantobie by the way?
ML:
I know it is right because there is a Tantobie, I think it is County
Durham somewhere. I'm not sure. It is yeah. It is.
AS:
What was the question?
ML:
Exactly. You're just trying to get away from the question! The question
is, what will you do when you hang up your boots, if this is your last
season?
AS:
Well I have, or the honest answer is, I do not know. I have signed a
contract with the BBC for three years which is this coming season and
another two. I have taken - finished my Uefa B licence, which is a
coaching qualification you need. And I will take my A licence again this
year. At some stage in my life I will need that because ... I am going to
stay in the game in some capacity whether that's in management or whether
that is going into the media, I haven't made my decision yet. Hopefully I
will have a choice.
ML:
Are taking the badges strange for top players, is it like going back to
school, filling in books and having to put cones out for players who will
be looking at you and thinking, I am embarrassed by the fact Alan Shearer
is putting the cones out for me?
AS:
It is strange but they tell us we have to do them so what choice have we
got? I don't know how many games I have played over the years, you would
think there would be a quicker way of getting players through,
international players through who have played 50 or 60 games for their
country, but everyone has to do it so why should we be any different?
ML:
In terms of managing Newcastle United, I know you have always gone on
record, it is not a secret you would like to do it one day.
AS:
I think I will give management a crack one day without doubt. Hopefully
that will be Newcastle one day, when that one day will be I do not know. I
really couldn't tell you, and that is me being honest.
ML:
We are going to Colin in Chester-le-Street in a second. We will take a
quick break.
ML:
The commentaries are back this Saturday, the Newcastle-Gateshead Cup or
the Gateshead-Newcastle Cup, I'm not sure what the title is. The man
opposite me will desperately be trying to lift it when Sunday comes around.
But on Saturday afternoon at 3:00pm, we are on air from 2:00pm, Newcastle
against Glasgow Rangers. You can phone Alan Shearer, text in or bbc.co.uk/tyne/sport.
Let's go to Colin in Chester-le-Street, Colin you have been hanging on,
what is your point to Alan Shearer?
COLIN:
Hi Alan.
AS:
Hi Colin.
C:
Just the one point, the query you had before, Tantobie is in Stanley.
AS:
OK, thanks.
ML:
It has turned into a geography phone-in now!
AS:
You do not know how many penalties I have missed over the years do you?
C:
Not really because I am a Sunderland supporter!
AS:
I will be looking forward to this question then!
C:
As the skipper of Newcastle, how do you manage to psyche the team up on
a Derby game to get the best out of the players when both teams know there
is that much involved and passion is already riding high?
AS:
That is a simple answer, if you have to psyche anybody up to play in a
Derby, any Derby whether that is Newcastle-Sunderland, Liverpool-Everton,
Celtic-Rangers, whoever. If you have to psyche them up or get them going
for a game like that then they should not be in the dressing room.
ML:
Obviously it has come up before because of the number of overseas
players in the game, there is a problem there, isn't there, on some
occasions?
AS:
I think if we can get the great foreigners in like Zola, like Henry,
like Bergkamp, like Desailly, like those players who the kids who are
coming through are going to learn from, that is fantastic. I think we have
had a problem over the years that there have been a lot of foreigners in
and a lot of them have not been good enough and maybe stifled the chances
of youngsters coming through. You cannot blame that on managers because
the prices of English or British players is extortionate. They have no
choice but to really look abroad, try and bring some bargains in. When
they do that they are not going to get everyone right and that is when
problems are created.
ML:
Going back to what you have said before, an e-mail in from John Byrne in
Bedlington. I would like to ask Alan what it is really like to live the
Geordie dream, to wear that No. 9 shirt and play at St James'? It is
something most of us can only dream of and give our right arm for. You
quite literally have dreamt the dream haven't you?
AS:
Without doubt. I am doing what thousands and thousands and thousands of
people would love to do. Obviously a lot of them being Geordies. What I
would say is try and put yourself in my position. It is probably
impossible because of the feeling I get walking out at St James's Park in
front of 52,000, wearing the No. 9 shirt - which is a very special number
anyway - and wearing the captain's armband. It really does not get any
better than that. I'm fortunate enough, I have that feeling every week.
ML:
Do you ever wish you weren't Alan Shearer, are there times when you
think to yourself, this is just a bit too much, either in your personal
life or with regard to the kids or whatever?
AS:
No. Not at all. Never. I think I realise I am in a very fortunate
position. I get paid for doing something I love and get well paid as
people will point out. How many people can say they get paid for doing
something they love and look forward to getting up in the morning, whether
it is sunshine, raining or snowing. I'm in such a fortunate position,
there is never a time, sometimes the privacy thing can be hard, and to
walk round Newcastle can be hard, but the advantages far, far outweigh the
disadvantages.
ML:
It also begs the question, and this is with a bit of sympathy for the
aforementioned chairman whose money is very valuable to the football club,
do you feel you are irreplaceable? A lot of people, I for one have gone on
record as saying because of the whole product, the fact you are the
Premiership's greatest-ever goalscorer, the fact you are a Geordie, the
fact you have dreamt the dream, there is not another one to come along it
is there? So somewhere along the line, whoever replaces you will have a
little bit missing and will not have that rapport with the fans?
AS:
They might not have the rapport with the fans but they can still be
built up as long as they come in and score goals. You know as well as I
know that anyone that comes up here and scores goals on a regular basis
will be worshipped. That has always been the case. Always has been, always
will be. When you are in football I think you must never get bitter, you
must never get twisted and you must always realise that it is like a clock.
You start off and you are tick, tick, tick, tick, tick, and you come
round. Someone will come in and replace you and that is the fact of life.
As we said earlier, I have been living the dream for I don't know how many
years now, 17 or 18 years I have been in the game and I have another year
and time is not on my side. But when I go away someone else will come in.
And so long as you understand that, and realise that, and do not get upset
when that happens, and you should not get upset because that has always
been the case.
ML:
You are listening to Alan Shearer on BBC Radio Newcastle with us though
until 8pm, taking your calls. A young man at the age of only 10 has got a
long time on that clock ahead of him, Neil from Seaham, you're through to
Alan Shearer.
NEIL:
Hello.
AS:
Hello Neil.
N:
I was just going to ask you, why would you want to retire when you are
such a good player?
AS:
That is very kind of you. Thanks very much. Just because I want to
retire at the top. I think in my opinion it is always best to do that and
for people to remember you as a very good player. For the last eight years
here that Newcastle I have managed to score goals on a regular basis and I
want people to remember me, to have been a very good player and to have
been a player that always scored goals. I think in a year's time it will
be best for me to do that and to do something else.
ML:
Do you think he should retire Neil, or do you want him to stay?
N:
I want him to stay.
AS:
Thanks very much. You are very kind.
ML:
If he goes, are you going to be his replacement?
N:
No.
AS:
Why not?
ML:
Definitely not?
AS:
Do you play football?
N:
Yes.
AS:
What position?
N:
Goalkeeper.
AS:
You haven't been my favourite players over the years, you goalkeepers. I
hope you turn out to be a new Shay Given anyway.
ML:
Thanks for your call Neil. That was Neil from Seaham, aged 10. There was
actually a question in these e-mails, millions of them, I cannot find it,
I will ask you anyway, I cannot remember who it was from, I apologise if
they are listening online somewhere around the world. Have you ever
thought about being anything other and a centre-forward. I think the
question was; if you could play anywhere else, if you had to play anywhere
else, where would you play?
AS:
I was one of these greedy little scruffy kids at school that I thought I
could play any where. I took the free kicks, I took the throw-ins, I took
the corner kicks and wanted to take everything. It was the buzz of scoring
goals that got me into that position if you like. I think you are actually
born with a talent to be in the right place at the right time and sniff
out where that ball is going to land in the box. Is it going to land at
your feet and are you going to put it in the net? I think it is difficult
to actually teach someone that. You can coach them to be a better finisher.
But I'm not too sure you can coach them to be in the right place at the
right time.
ML:
Another e-mail from Nemo in Kendal. Would you say rejecting Manchester
United and signing for a side that has won nothing in 50 years was a
mistake?
AS:
No. Not at all. It was a big decision for me and Man Utd wasn't the only
club that I could have went to have gone on to win silverware since I left.
That's life. That is the decision I made. I am very happy and very pleased
with my decision. No regrets, Man Utd have been a great team, still are a
great team and will continue to win silverware for however many years. But
so are Newcastle without the silverware.
ML:
A quick text, do not forget the text, just a quick one, you can answer
this as briefly as you like. Alan in Shetland, a long, long way away, will
you shake a Ruud Gullit's hand at St James's Park this weekend?
AS:
If I see him, I haven't got a problem with that. People have opinions,
his opinion was that he did not want to play me and that was fine. I've
never been bitter or twisted about that, that's his opinion. Ruud Gullit I
thought was a very good coach. Some of the sessions he put on a at his
time here in Newcastle were excellent. It didn't work out for him, for
whatever reason, and he wasn't here and left after that Sunderland game,
so no, if I see him I will shake his hand. I'm not like that.
ML:
Going back to the badges and the fact you are taking your badges, the
fact you are not ruling out any management role in the future, you have
talked about Ruud Gullit, you might have just learnt one or two things
from Ruud Gullit as a coach, people are talking about Sir Bobby Robson and
the fact he could groom you as a coach, one name that has not been thrown
into the frame that I would like to ask you about, Kenny Dalglish. You had
him at Blackburn, you had him at Newcastle, he is the only player in
recent years - great, great player - who has gone on to be a great
manager. And that is something you might have to break the mould once
again. Is he more of a mentor or potentially more of a mentor because I
know you are close him and you rate him highly than perhaps the Uefa
coaching badges or Bobby Robson or Ruud Gullit or any other coaches you
have come under?
AS:
Absolutely. I will not have a bad word said against Kenny because as a
person, fantastic. As a manager I think he was fantastic as well. He did
not have the best of times up here, he won trophies at Liverpool as a
manager and as a player. He won the title at Blackburn as a manager. Some
of his signings did not work out for him at Newcastle but I tell you, if
you ask any player who was here when Kenny was manager, they will not have
a bad word said against him because for a player he was fantastic, he
treated you as a man. He treated you how you wanted to be treated. You got
out of him what you wanted to get out of him and he was great for us as
players, certainly here at Newcastle and definitely at Blackburn. I have
played with some great managers and coaches over the years and so if I can
pick up some good things and bad things off the people I have worked with
then it should stand me in good stead. You know as well as I do, that does
not guarantee you anything. I think coaching, coaching and management can
be sometimes two completely different things. As a manager you manage. As
a coach you go and coach players.
ML:
Especially nowadays as well.
AS:
Without doubt. For me they are two completely different jobs. But I
think management interests me more than coaching. But of course you are
going to have to have your badges to be a manager.
ML:
Is it an incentive, just very briefly, to break that mould and to say to
people I can be a great player who goes on to be a good manager? Because
there have been so, going back to the Moores and the Charltons etc, there
have been so few. Is that an incentive for you to succeed as a player and
as a manager?
AS:
I think the bigger incentive is to go on and win things. Whatever
happens will happen. But as I said, because you have been a decent player
does not guarantee you anything when you go into management or coaching.
Let's talk about teams who have won things. Brian from Washington has been
hanging on, Brian you are through to the Newcastle United skipper.
BRIAN:
Good evening Alan. Alan you have been a legend at Newcastle and I am
sure your last season is going to be another great season for you and
hopefully it will be a great season for us as well.
AS:
I hope so.
ML:
Alan what I'd like your opinion on, it is interesting you said earlier
that you did not think we could break into the top three. I just wondered
what your view was on Euro 2004 when the Greeks, against all odds, won the
competition and really the teams with all the superstars did not do
anything. Yet the team that was organised, well prepared, disciplined and
played a game plan, actually won a trophy. Do you think that could be
translated into the Premier League?
AS:
I think for Newcastle, for other clubs, I think for other clubs it
already has because if you look at Charlton, if you look at Bolton, if you
look at Birmingham, I am not being disrespectful to those clubs, but they
never spend millions out on players but they always have this fantastic
record of upsetting the odds if you like. First and foremost they will go
into every season as looking to gain Premiership status year in year out
but they have gone one step further in that and for a long time, last
season, those three were up challenging ourselves and Liverpool for that
fourth spot. You are right, it is a great point, it just goes to show you
when you have got a bunch of players who are willing to work their socks
off and have a bunch of players who are well organised and told what to
do, and you go out and do it, they were not in the most gifted side in
Euro 2004, Greece, by far. But they were well organised, well drilled,
they were not the most entertaining side but I tell you what, they were
tough to break down.
ML:
Let's go back to the text. Johnny has texted. How important are
pre-season results and performances as preparation for the new season?
Good luck Alan, that is from Johnny. Bearing in mind, two games in
Thailand, did not win either. And then two games subsequently and again
faltered a lot.
AS:
Yeah, one game in Thailand, one game in Hong Kong. Very difficult to
play in those conditions. The heat, and probably more importantly the
humidity, was very tough and 90% of the squad only played half games in
both of those. But the best thing that you can get out of pre-season games
is to go through the games, work very hard to get your match fitness. The
most important thing for me is for the squad to try and stay injury-free.
I have been in pre-seasons where we have won every game, where I have
scored lots of goals, but we have got off to a bad start. I have also been
in pre-season where I haven't won any and I haven't scored but I have
scored straight away at the league and we have got off to a decent start.
You have to be right for that all-important game. Middlesbrough, by far,
is the most important thing in the season. That is what you have to get
fit for. That is what you have to be match fit for. But confidence is a
good thing to have. In an ideal world you will go through all the
pre-season and win all the games but of course that is not going to happen.
ML:
10 minutes left, millions of e-mails, texts and phones. We will go back
to the phones, Mick in Stockton is on. Mick you are through to Alan
Shearer, what is your question?
MICK MCMANUS:
Hello Alan. Mick McManus from Stockton. You have got Kluivert alongside
you now. I am very delighted he is playing with you. How do you think you
will hit off the season with Patrick Kluivert?
AL:
First and foremost the manager hasn't told me whether I will be playing
up front with him or told me I will be playing at all, or him at all to be
honest. But what I will say, he probably lost his way for 18 months, two
years. But if you look at his name and the clubs he has played for and his
games and his goals record, I think you will find it is excellent. If he
can get it right here at Newcastle, he is 28 year old and they say that
you are in your prime at 27, 28, 29, 30. If that is the case then
Newcastle have got a fantastic player on their hands and he could be a big
player for us, there is no doubt about that.
ML:
Can you deny or confirm the story doing the rounds that you played a
part in him coming to the North East and showed him round and told him
about the North East?
AS:
Yeah. I can deny that. I have seen that report and I do not know where
it came from. Whoever Newcastle have brought in over the last eight years
I can assure you none of them have anything to do with me, that is not my
job, that is the manager's and chairman's job to bring in players and let
players go.
ML:
He has scored a few goals himself, Patrick Kluivert, in terms of your
goals, Martin West of Shropshire was one of a good few people who e-mailed
in questions regarding the goal celebration. Martin says, it has been
years now, ever thought about changing the celebration? I know what the
answer is going to be!
AS:
Why should I change it in my last season?
ML:
Remember that time you did change it?
AS:
I did. I changed it at Blackburn I think it was ...
ML:
Robin Hood and the bow and arrow!
AS:
I got a bit of ribbing for that as well. I do not know how it happened
that one arm celebration. It happened many years ago and for whatever
reason I have stuck to it. It served me good in the past, I'm not go to
change it for my last year. I hope I'm going to score a few anyway so you
can see it for the last time this year.
ML:
And it doesn't exactly wear you out, it is sort of preserving your
energy type celebration?
AS:
Eh, at my age you have got to do that. I certainly do not run very far
after I have celebrated if you noticed that.
ML:
A couple of callers who do not want to go to air. One, Ken from the
coast, who would Alan like to see replace him? I know it is not going to
be your decision ultimately but can you think of anybody off the top of
your head who you would like to see coming to the club?
AS:
If Patrick is a big hit then they might not have to look very far to
replace me. Shola has signed a new five-year contract at Newcastle now so
he wants an opportunity to do that. So there is two big players there that
have a great chance and a foot in the door already.
ML:
Billy from Redcar just wants to say, thanks Alan for everything he has
done. Sue from Cheshire who is up for the game on Saturday, she like a few
others on the e-mail, wants to ask the question, does Alan still creosote
his fence?
AS:
Only when I win championships!
ML:
These sort of stories never go away, do you tire of them?
AS:
I think what happened was, if I remember rightly, we won the league at
Blackburn and the following day my father in-law was up and he was doing
some work for us on the house and I think it was him that was doing the
fence and I went out I took him some drinks and it has always been
labelled that I went out and creosoted my fence!
ML:
Five or six minutes remaining, we will try and lighten it up a little
bit in these final sessions. If Alan had not have been a footballer, what
job would he have done? That is from Mel in Newcastle on the text. You
must have been asked it is a million times.
AS:
I haven't got a clue, I really haven't because football was all I knew
at school. The teachers were forever telling me to concentrate on my
school work because the chances of me being a footballer were slim. But I
was only ever interested in football and did not really like school if I I
am honest because I always had confidence and belief that I was going to
be one. Thankfully I did because a I haven't got a clue what I would have
been.
ML:
Nicola from Coventry wants to know on the e-mail, which young players do
you admire?
AS:
I admire all young players, because you know why? Because, like the rest
of us, they are under so much pressure. And there is so much spotlight on
them nowadays they can't do a thing wrong. If you put yourselves in the
young players' position nowadays, that they are not married, they are
single, they get paid a hell of a lot of money, what do they do with their
spare time? We train three hours a day at most during the season so they
have a hell of a lot of time on their hands, so what do they do with it?
They have all this money to spend. So I have got a little sympathy with
the young players coming through. Any one of them that make it, I have
great respect for.
ML:
Do you have sympathy for ones who stray a little, ones who step out of
line because the temptations are so great and because they have a lot of
lot of money in their pockets?
AS:
I understand why they do it because the temptations are massive. As I've
said they have a lot of time on their hands, they have got a hell of a lot
of money, they are living on their own a lot of them, so what do they do
with their time and they have to find something to do, so I can understand
why a lot of them get into small problems.
ML:
I asked Gary Speed this during the summer, are footballers paid too much
nowadays?
AS:
That is not our fault. That is not our problem. That's been my answer
over the years, if someone wants to pay you £30,000, £40,000, £50,000 a
week then that's fine. If they were in that same position, I know one
thing, they would not turn it down.
BBC Tyne would like to say a big thank you to Tom Jones for providing this
transcript.
